9 Best Organic Mattress Toppers For Non-Toxic Sleep (2023)
The Good Trade editors endorse products we’ve personally researched, tested, and genuinely love. Learn more about our methodology and business model here.
Why use a mattress topper? Easy, the benefits range from health to wealth! Mattress toppers provide additional comfort and support while removing pressure points and they help to reduce motion transfer each time your partner (or pet!) makes a move. Investing in a mattress topper also extends the life of your mattress by acting as a buffer for sweat and wear.
Most of us will spend nearly a third of our lives sleeping on chemical-laden mattresses covered by flame retardants that are proven to negatively impact hormones, immunity, reproduction, and our nervous systems. Purchasing a new organic mattress is a big investment and an organic mattress topper can help offset the off-gassing from your mattress until it’s time to update the whole set.
We test every product featured in our guides so we can provide you with sincere recommendations that meet strict sustainability standards as well as lifestyle considerations. Below we’ve found the best organic mattress toppers that source only natural and organic materials, support small businesses and safe working conditions, use eco-friendly or carbon-conscious methods, and give back to those in need.
Sleep sweeter with any one of these picks! ☁️
Shopping for a new mattress, too? Try these affordable organic mattress brands and organic pillows.
Best Overall | Most Affordable | Most Organic
1. Birch
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton, organic wool, natural latex
Price of Queen Topper | $499
Whereas most toppers are two inches, Birch’s three-inch Mattress Topper provides extra-cushioned support. Using Birch’s proprietary wool, organic cotton, and natural latex, these GOTS and GREENGUARD Gold certified toppers are handmade in the USA and shipped straight to you within 10 business days. You’re less than two weeks away from your best night’s rest.
2. Brentwood Home
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton, natural Dunlop latex, CertiPUR-US® Tencel-based BioFoam
Price of Queen Topper | $229
Inspired by the natural resources found in California, Brentwood Home wanted to create softer, simpler mattress toppers. These GREENGUARD Gold toppers turn anti-microbial organic latex, organic cotton cover, plant-based Tencel fibers, and sustainable New Zealand wool into eco-friendly sleep surfaces you’ll love. They’re uniquely designed to have multiple comfort zones, no pressure points, and limited motion transfer.
*SAVE 10% SITEWIDE USING CODE GOODTRADE AT CHECKOUT
3. Avocado
Organic Materials | GOLS certified organic latex, GOTS certified organic wool & cotton
Price of Queen Topper | $649
Avocado, the sustainable and organic bedding giant, offers mattress toppers sourced from the finest natural materials: GOTS & GOLS certified organic latex, wool, and cotton. The result is a luxurious topper that better supports your body’s natural curves. Each night when you hop into bed, you’ll know right down to the farm where your topper came from, and that it’s MADE SAFE certified. Plus, it’s fully carbon-neutral and a portion of all purchases support environmental causes.
*SAVE AN ADDITIONAL 10% WITH CODE GOODTRADE AT CHECKOUT
4. Parachute
Organic Materials | OEKO-TEX certified sustainable materials, free from artificial softeners & toxic chemicals
Price of Queen Topper | $249–$379
Parachute’s mattress toppers are made to be the final layer of coziness to make your bed your absolute favorite destination. Choose from down or down alternative, and rest easy knowing that the RDS-certified down means no live-plucking produced the cozy fill. The down alternative is 100% hypoallergenic, and both are guaranteed to help you sink into your dreamiest sleep yet. Our founder swears by Parachute’s down alternative topper for a plush added layer that gives that cloud-like hotel feeling to a regular mattress.
5. PlushBeds
Organic Materials | Organic wool, organic cotton
Price of Queen Topper | $999
When it comes to plushness we turn to the experts—PlushBeds! The brand’s three inch organic wool topper is made from temperature-regulating wool that’s never been chemically treated and surrounded by a 100 percent GOTS-Certified organic cotton sateen cover. Plus, it’s a 2021 Good Housekeeping Best Bedding Award-winner, so you know you can’t go wrong.
6. Coyuchi
Organic Materials | Wool, GOTS certified organic cotton
Price of Queen Topper | $498
Coyuchi wants your bed to be the comfortable oasis you’ve dreamed of—and on. Made with wool ethically sourced from northern California, Coyuchi’s climate-beneficial wool topper will keep you warm throughout the cold months, and sweat-free in the hot ones. Naturally hypoallergenic and dust-resistant, this topper is also an A+ option for sensitive sleepers. As with all orders, Coyuchi gives back through 1% for the Planet.
7. Tuft & Needle
Organic Materials | CertiPUR-US® certified foam
Price of Queen Topper | $250
Suffer from shoulder or hip pain? Tuft & Needle offers a sustainable, simple solution with its natural foam mattress topper. Responsive to your needs, this two-inch topper will help relieve those achy pressure points and keep you comfortable all night long. For the ultimate in safety, each topper is both CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold certified. And as a bonus, it’s one of the most affordable eco-friendly toppers on our list.
8. Happsy
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton, GOLS certified organic latex
Price of Queen Topper | $399
Happsy wants everyone to have that “luxury hotel” experience with its USA-made Organic Mattress Topper. The GOLS certified organic latex is surrounded with a layer of GOTS certified organic cotton for a deeper, thicker feel—without the harmful chemicals. The team behind the first certified organic mattress-in-a-box has done it again.
9. Boll & Branch
Organic Materials | Organic cotton, wool
Price of Queen Topper | $658
Boll & Branch believes in humanity, responsibility, and intention with all of its bedding and bath products. Mindfully made with free-range New Zealand sheep’s wool and organic cotton, the two-inch Mattress Topper adds a pillowy, deluxe feel to any mattress. Knowing that each topper is made ethically and responsibly, we’ll all sleep a little better. (The brand offers sheets, too, which we personally tried—check out our Boll & Branch review to see how we snoozed.)
Featured image from Brentwood Home
